Editor's Note: We like to use this blog to provide a variety of different opinions from people in the field. Interesting comments, strange stories, and even wacky theories -they're all fair game. That said, the opinions reflected herein do not necessarily reflect those of Muscle & Fitness. Bodybuilding Purists
One thing I love about bodybuilding purists is that they train so hard that their eyes bleed and their muscles are almost tearing through their skin. They simply don't know any other way. They want to grow and when their bodies want to give up they simply don't take no for an answer.
On the other hand, many bodybuilding purists are so focused on the tradition of how things have always been done that it is darn near impossible to get them to accept anything different. Below I'm going to give my own experience and beliefs, trying to slay a couple sacred cows of purist bodybuilding. Get out your torches and pitchforks ready. I'm assuming the hunt for me will be on at dusk.
Purist Belief #1 - To build huge legs you have to squat To me, this is complete and utter nonsense. Squats are just one of many ways to build great legs. In fact, I'll even go so far as to say that you can develop an equally impressive set of wheels without ever putting a bar across your back.
With my own clients squats are a rarity. I do use them, but they're the exception and not the rule. Instead, we use split squats, lunges, Bulgarian squats, and many other single legged variations to load the legs. In fact, many of our hamstring movements are single legged variations too.
In a single leg movement, the external load used (the weight you hold that puts stress on the spine) will be less, but since you're only doing one leg at a time the stress on the muscles themselves can be the exact same.
For example, if you're doing a 400 pound squat at a body weight of 200 pounds you're squatting a total of 600 pounds (that's 300 pounds per leg).
If you were to do a Bulgarian squat instead, you still have your body weight of 200 pounds so you would only need to hold an additional 100 pounds to put 300 pounds of stress on that leg. That's 300 pounds less additional load being put on your spine with the same amount of work being done on the leg!
Purist Belief #2 - You have to deadlift from the floor I'll say this once. Unless you're a competitive powerlifter you absolutely do not have to do your deadlifts from the floor. If you're just trying to look good, I see no reason why you should even bother.
As you read above, I do like to limit spinal compression, but I'm not totally against any movement that produces it. In fact, if I had to pick on exercise that allowed compression I'd pick deadlifts over squats any day of the week. These emphasize the posterior chain and can create incredible muscular development from the back of your knees to the back of your neck.
The main problem comes when some old school bodybuilder tries to make you feel like you're less of a man if you don't pull from the floor. The bottom line for me is that very few people have the appropriate hip mobility or physical stature to allow them to pull from the floor with perfect form. Instead, when they set up or start to pull their lower backs begin to round and they wonder why they have back pain instead of back muscles.
By starting the deadlift on a low box or pulling from the pins in the power rack you can allow yourself to start from a position where your spine is in neutral. Do a few sets of these and your back will feel fried the next day, but not in a bad way. More importantly, this can help keep your back healthy for your whole training career.
Whenever it comes to lifting, be critical and don't just drink the proverbial kool aid just because "this is the way it has always been done".
Think. Train. Grow.
Mark Young is an exercise and nutrition consultant from Ontario, Canada. Check out his website at
www.markyoungtrainingsystems.com to sign up for his FREE information packed newsletter.